What a stay interview is for

An exit interview asks people why they are leaving, when it is too late to change their mind. A stay interview asks the same kind of question while there’s still time to act. You might get one because your company has a formal programme, or simply because a good manager wants to check in.

It usually lasts about 30 minutes to an hour and tends to be informal. It isn’t really an interview in the usual sense, and you don’t need to sell yourself or prepare a speech.

Stay interview Exit interview Performance review
When While you’re happy, or nearly so After you resign On a regular schedule
About What keeps you or could push you away Why you are leaving How you are doing
Who it can help You and the team Future employees You and your manager
Effect on pay Not meant to have one None Often direct

Questions you may hear

Managers tend to draw on a similar list. It helps to think about your answers beforehand:

  • What do you look forward to when you start work?
  • What makes you dread a day at work?
  • What would you change about your job if you could?
  • What’s keeping you here?
  • Have you thought about leaving recently? What prompted it?
  • What talents or skills are you not using?
  • What would you like to learn this year?
  • Where do you want your career path to go in the next couple of years?
  • How can I better support you?
  • Is there anything you think is unfair, or that gets in your way?

How to answer well

Think of it as a rare chance to influence your own job, not a test.

Decide on your top two or three issues. A long list of complaints is easy to ignore. Pick what would make the biggest difference to you, whether that’s pay, workload, flexibility, growth or how decisions get made.

Be specific, and suggest something. “I’m not happy” gives your manager nothing to work with. Try describing what happened, why it matters and what would help:

“I enjoy the client work, and it’s the reason I’ve stayed. But I’ve spent most of this year on reporting. I’d like to lead one client project by next quarter. Could we find a way to make that work?”

Talk about problems, not people. You can say that decisions reach your team too late without naming the person you blame. It is more likely to lead to change, and it won’t come back to haunt you.

Be careful about what you reveal. Your manager may be fully sincere, but anything you say could still be shared. Telling them you are interviewing elsewhere could change how they see you, and it’s rarely necessary. It’s fine to say “I think about what’s next from time to time”, then explain what would keep you here.

What to do afterwards

The conversation is only worth having if something follows from it.

  1. Follow up in writing. Send a short message that sums up what you discussed and any agreed next steps.
  2. Agree on a time to check in. A date a month or two away keeps it from being forgotten.
  3. Keep your side of it. If you asked for a stretch project, be ready to do it well.
  4. Notice what happens. If nothing changes after a reasonable time, raise it again. If it still goes nowhere, you’ve learned something useful about your chances of growing here.

If you do end up exploring other jobs, remember the things you named as important. They make an excellent checklist for your next employer, and they can help you weigh any counteroffer that comes your way when you hand in your notice.

FAQ

Is a stay interview a sign that I'm about to be let go?

No, usually the opposite. Companies hold stay interviews with people they want to keep. If your manager calls it that, and asks about your goals and what would make you happy, it's most likely a good sign.

Should I tell the truth in a stay interview?

Be honest but thoughtful. Raising the problems that matter is the whole point of the conversation, and it's your chance to get them fixed. You don't need to share everything, though, and it's generally wise not to say you are job hunting unless you are ready for the consequences.

Can I ask for a raise in a stay interview?

Yes, if pay is really an issue for you, since this is one of the most natural times to bring it up. Your manager may not be able to agree on the spot, so come with market data and ask what the next step would be. You can always follow up afterward.

What is the difference between a stay interview and a performance review?

A performance review looks at how well you are doing, and it may affect your pay or rating. A stay interview looks at how the job is going for you. It's meant to be about listening, and it shouldn't be used to rate you.

Daniel Peris

Written by

Daniel Peris

Entrepreneur and product builder

On the internet since 1995 and launching online products since 2009, from one of the first app marketing agencies to tools like Pixelin. Writes about LinkedIn, resumes and standing out online.