Two meanings

The word is used in two situations that look quite different:

Countering a job offer Your employer’s counteroffer
Who makes it You, the candidate Your current employer
When After you receive an offer After you resign or say you are leaving
Goal Better terms in the new job Keeping you in the current job
Main risk Small: the offer stays the same Bigger: trust and the reasons you left

When you counter a job offer

Countering is the core of salary negotiation. After you receive an offer letter or a verbal offer, you reply with what you would need to accept.

“Thank you, I’d love to join. Given my experience leading similar projects, I was hoping for a base of 68,000 rather than 62,000. If we can get there, I’m ready to sign this week.”

Tips:

  • Ask for everything at once: salary, start date, remote days. Don’t add new requests after they agree.
  • Give reasons: market data, your skills, a competing offer.
  • Show you want the job. A counter is a request, not a threat.
  • Be ready for a partial yes. They may meet you halfway, or offer a signing bonus instead of more base pay.

When your employer makes a counteroffer

You resign, and your manager comes back with more money, a new title or a promotion to keep you. It feels flattering, and sometimes it is exactly what you wanted. But think it through:

  • Why were you leaving? If it was pay alone, a fair raise may fix it. If it was the manager, the culture or a lack of growth, money won’t change that.
  • Why now? If they could pay more today, why not before you resigned?
  • How will it feel later? Some people find their loyalty is questioned after accepting, or that the next raise is slower.
  • What about the other company? Backing out of an accepted offer burns a bridge, and in some cases a recruiter will remember it.

It also helps to ask what will change besides money. A new title, a different team, a clear promotion date or a change in your workload are real fixes; a one-off raise on its own often is not.

There is no single right answer. Some counteroffers work out well, especially when they come with real changes, not just money.

How to decide

Write down your reasons for looking, then score each option against them. Compare the full total compensation, not just the base salary. Ask for any counteroffer in writing, with dates. If you are still unsure, imagine you had received both offers on the same day as an outsider: which job would you pick? And whatever you choose, tell the other side promptly and politely. Careers are long and people move around.

FAQ

Should I accept a counteroffer from my current employer?

Only if money was the main reason you wanted to leave and the company will also fix what else bothered you. If you were leaving because of the manager, the work or a lack of growth, a raise rarely changes that for long.

Is it rude to counter a job offer?

No. Recruiters expect many candidates to negotiate. A polite, specific counter with reasons is normal and rarely costs you the offer.

Can I use a competing offer to get a counteroffer?

You can mention a real competing offer to a prospective employer or to your current one, and it often helps. Never invent one; it can be checked and it damages trust if found out.

How long should I take to answer a counteroffer?

A day or two is reasonable. Ask for the counteroffer in writing, think about why you started looking, and don't let either side rush you.

From the BestiaryMeet The Counteroffer, the monster →
Daniel Peris

Written by

Daniel Peris

Entrepreneur and product builder

On the internet since 1995 and launching online products since 2009, from one of the first app marketing agencies to tools like Pixelin. Writes about LinkedIn, resumes and standing out online.