How a performance review works

Most reviews follow a similar cycle:

  1. Self-review: you write a short summary of your results, strengths and areas to improve.
  2. Feedback: your manager, and sometimes colleagues, give their view. When colleagues and reports are asked too, it is called 360-degree feedback.
  3. Rating: many companies give a score, such as “meets expectations” or “exceeds expectations”.
  4. Review meeting: you and your manager discuss the results and agree on next steps.
  5. Goals: new targets for the next period, sometimes as OKRs.

The outcome can affect pay, bonuses and promotion. A poor review may lead to a performance improvement plan.

How to prepare

  • Keep a record during the year. Note wins, numbers, thank-you messages and projects as they happen. It is very hard to remember them all at review time.
  • Compare against your goals. Show what you achieved for each, and explain honestly what got in the way.
  • Quantify your results: revenue, time saved, customers helped, projects delivered.
  • Bring your questions and asks: a raise, a promotion, training or a new project. A review is one of the best moments to raise them.
  • Listen to the feedback, even when it is hard. Ask for concrete examples and what “good” would look like.

A bonus for your resume

A well-kept list of results for your review is also the best raw material for your resume. Results you can measure make strong bullet points, and they make your next job search much easier.

FAQ

How often are performance reviews done?

Traditionally once a year. Many companies now run them twice a year or quarterly, often with lighter check-ins in between.

Are performance reviews linked to pay?

Often, yes. Many companies use review ratings to decide raises, bonuses and promotions, sometimes in a separate meeting a few weeks later.

Can I disagree with my performance review?

Yes. Stay calm, ask for specific examples, and share your own evidence. If you still disagree, many companies let you add written comments or ask HR for a second opinion.

What should I write in a self-review?

Your main results with numbers, the goals you met or missed and why, what you learned, and what you want to focus on next. Be honest and specific rather than modest or vague.

Daniel Peris

Written by

Daniel Peris

Entrepreneur and product builder

On the internet since 1995 and launching online products since 2009, from one of the first app marketing agencies to tools like Pixelin. Writes about LinkedIn, resumes and standing out online.