How golden handcuffs work

The idea is simple: part of your pay arrives later, and only if you are still there. Employers use this to keep people they would struggle to replace. The phrase is an informal one, and you will rarely see it in a contract, but the arrangements behind it are common, especially in tech, finance, law and senior management.

Type How it holds you What happens if you leave early
RSUs Shares arrive over several years Unvested shares are normally lost
Stock options The right to buy shares builds up over time Unvested options are lost; vested ones may expire soon after you go
Retention bonus Paid if you stay until a set date You miss it, or repay it if it was paid upfront
Signing bonus with clawback Paid at the start with a minimum stay You may repay some or all of it
Deferred bonus or pension Paid or kept only after a certain time Part of it may be forfeited
Rich benefits Hard to find elsewhere You lose them, though nothing has to be repaid

The handcuffs also tighten quietly. If you keep receiving new stock grants each year, there is always another batch about to vest, so there is never an obviously free moment to leave.

Work out what you would really lose

The number in your head is often larger or smaller than the real one. Before deciding anything, write down:

  1. What vests in the next 12 months, and on which dates. Leaving a few weeks after a vesting date can save you a lot.
  2. What you would have to repay, including any clawback on bonuses or relocation costs.
  3. The value after tax. Stock and bonuses are often taxed heavily, so use the money you would actually keep.
  4. How realistic the stock value is. Shares in a listed company have a market price. Shares in a private company may be worth much less than the last valuation, and may be hard to sell.

Then compare it with the other side: the total compensation of the jobs you could get, not just the salary.

“Staying until March gets me about 18,000 after tax. A move now pays 12,000 more per year and gets me the promotion I have been waiting for. Over two years, leaving comes out ahead.”

Sums like this one will not make the decision for you, but they turn a vague fear into something you can actually weigh.

When staying is worth it, and when it is not

Staying can make sense if a big vesting date is close, if you are still learning, or if the extra money does something specific for you, like paying off debt or funding a career change next year.

It is time to think harder if your skills are going stale, your health is suffering, or you have been saying “just one more vest” for years. The money is visible, while the cost of staying is not: promotions you did not chase, skills you did not build, and a market that may have moved on without you.

If you do want to stay for now, set a date and a reason. Keep your resume current and your network warm in the meantime, so that when the date comes you have real options. If you are ready to go, plan your exit around the vesting schedule and leave on good terms.

FAQ

Are golden handcuffs a bad thing?

Not by themselves. They are real money, and staying a little longer to collect it can be a very sensible choice. They become a problem when the money is the only reason you stay and the job is hurting your health, your skills or your career.

Can a new employer buy me out of golden handcuffs?

Sometimes. Employers may offer a signing bonus or extra stock to make up for what you would give up, especially for senior hires. Bring a clear figure and be ready to show how you reached it, though they may not match all of it.

What happens to my unvested stock if I quit?

Usually you lose it on your last day, while shares that have already vested stay yours. Vested stock options often have a short window in which you must exercise them or lose them. Your grant documents set the exact rules, so read them before you resign.

Do I have to pay back a retention bonus if I leave?

If your agreement has a clawback clause and you leave before the agreed date, you may have to repay some or all of it. Some agreements reduce the amount over time. Also check whether you would repay the amount before or after tax, as it can make a big difference.

From the BestiaryMeet Golden Handcuffs, the monster →
Daniel Peris

Written by

Daniel Peris

Entrepreneur and product builder

On the internet since 1995 and launching online products since 2009, from one of the first app marketing agencies to tools like Pixelin. Writes about LinkedIn, resumes and standing out online.