How stock options work

  1. Grant: you are given, say, 10,000 options with a strike price of $2.
  2. Vesting: you earn the right to use them over time, often four years with a one-year cliff (see vesting).
  3. Exercise: you pay the strike price to buy the vested shares.
  4. Sale: if there is a market for the shares, you can sell them later.

Example: your 10,000 options have a $2 strike price. A few years later the shares are worth $10. Exercising costs $20,000 and gives you shares worth $100,000, a paper gain of $80,000 before tax. If the shares are worth $1.50, the options are “underwater” and exercising makes no sense.

Options are especially common at startups and private companies, where the share price is low at the start and the hope is that it grows.

Stock options vs RSUs

Stock options RSUs
What you get The right to buy shares The shares themselves
Cost to you The strike price Nothing
If the price falls Can be worth zero Worth less, but rarely zero
Typical at Startups and early-stage companies Larger and listed companies
Main tax moment Usually exercise or sale Usually vesting

Tax, in general terms

Option tax is complex and depends heavily on the country and the type of plan. In the US, there are two main kinds:

  • ISOs (incentive stock options): can get favourable tax treatment if you meet holding rules, but may trigger alternative minimum tax.
  • NSOs (non-qualified stock options): the gain at exercise is usually taxed as ordinary income.

Other countries have their own schemes, such as EMI options in the UK, each with different rules. Exercising can create a tax bill even if you cannot yet sell the shares, which is a real risk at private companies.

This is general information, not tax or financial advice. If a lot is at stake, ask a tax or financial adviser.

Questions to ask about an option grant

  • How many options, and what is the strike price?
  • How many shares are outstanding in total? 10,000 options mean little without knowing what percentage that is.
  • What is the vesting schedule and cliff?
  • How long is the exercise window after leaving?
  • Can I exercise early, and are the options ISOs or NSOs (in the US)?

At a startup, treat options as a possible bonus, not as part of your guaranteed pay. Value your offer mainly on salary and benefits, and see options as the upside in your total compensation.

Once options vest, whether and when to exercise is a personal financial decision, and we cannot advise on it. Things people usually weigh up are the cost of exercising, the possible tax bill, how likely the company is to be sold or go public, and how much of their savings they want tied to one employer. Many people at private companies wait until a sale or IPO; others exercise early to start holding periods. A tax or financial adviser can look at your situation.

FAQ

What is a strike price?

The strike price, or exercise price, is the fixed price per share you pay to buy shares with your options. It is set when the options are granted, usually at the share's fair market value on that date. Options are only worth something if the shares later become worth more than that.

What does it mean to exercise stock options?

Exercising means paying the strike price to turn vested options into actual shares. You can usually exercise any time after vesting until the options expire, often ten years after grant, or within a shorter window after you leave the company.

Are stock options better than RSUs?

Neither is simply better. RSUs keep some value as long as the shares are worth anything. Options can be worth more if the company grows a lot, but can be worth nothing if the share price stays below the strike price. Options also cost money to exercise.

What happens to my options if I leave the company?

Unvested options are usually forfeited. Vested options normally have to be exercised within a set window, often 90 days in the US, or they are lost. Some companies offer longer windows, so check your grant agreement.

Daniel Peris

Written by

Daniel Peris

Entrepreneur and product builder

On the internet since 1995 and launching online products since 2009, from one of the first app marketing agencies to tools like Pixelin. Writes about LinkedIn, resumes and standing out online.